NATIONAL
CRIMINAL JURY INSTRUCTION COMPENDIUM
Instructions And Issues Omitted By The Pattern Instructions
VOLUME 17: DEATH PENALTY (Chapters 301-304)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Chapter 301: Death Penalty: Federal Constitutional Principles
301.1 The Death Eligibility Determination: Requirement Of Rational Narrowing
301.1.1 Death Eligibility: Rational Narrowing Is Constitutionally Required
301.1.2 Death Penalty: Narrowing Must Be Rational
301.1.3 Death Penalty: Narrowing Determination Must Be Made By Jury And Comport With 5th, 6th And 14th Amendments
301.1.4 Aggravating Factor Must Not Be So Vague That It Could Apply To Every Death-Eligible Murder
301.1.5 Challenge To Overly Broad Death Eligibility Scheme
301.1.6 Death Penalty: Specific Aggravating Factors
301.1.7 Death Penalty For Crimes Other Than Murder
301.2 Death Penalty: The Sentencing Determination -- Requirement Of Guided Discretion
301.2.1 Death Sentence Must Not Be Discriminatory, Arbitrary Or Capricious
301.2.2 Death Penalty: Guided Discretion -- Jury Must Not Have Too Much Discretion
301.2.3 Death Penalty: Guided Discretion -- Jury Must Not Have Too Little Discretion
301.2.4 Mandatory Death Improper For Murder By Life Prisoner
301.2.5 Death Can Be Mandatory After Mitigation Is Considered
301.2.6 Jury Must Accept Responsibility For Sentencing Decision
301.2.7 Death Penalty: Jury Must Understand Sentencing Discretion
301.3 Death Penalty: Aggravation
301.3.1 State May Identify Aggravating Factors
301.3.2 Death Penalty: Jury Consideration Of Nonstatutory Aggravation
301.3.3 Improper For The Jury To Consider Invalid Aggravating Factors For Death Eligibility
301.3.4 Death Penalty: Improper For The Jury To Consider Invalid Aggravating Factors For Sentencing
301.4 Death Penalty: Mitigation
301.4.1 Mitigation: General Principles
301.4.1.1 Death Penalty: The Jury Must Consider All Mitigating Evidence
301.4.1.2 Mitigation Can Emanate From The Offense Or The Offender
301.4.1.3 Death Penalty: Defining Mitigation For The Jury
301.4.1.4 Death Penalty: Improper Mitigating Evidence
301.4.1.5 Unanimity Not Required For Consideration Of Mitigation
301.4.1.6 Death: Constitution Requires Admission Of Relevant Mitigation Even If Not Admissible Under Traditional Rules Of Evidence
301.4.1.7 Death Penalty: Jury Must Be Allowed To Give Full Effect To Mitigating Circumstances
301.4.1.8 Death Penalty: Prosecutor Misconduct Which Forecloses Juror Consideration Of Mitigation
301.4.2 Death Penalty: Specific Mitigation
301.4.2.1 Death Penalty: Sympathy As Mitigation
301.4.2.2 Death Penalty: Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder As Mitigation
301.4.2.3 Death Penalty: Miscellaneous Mitigating Factors
301.5 Death Penalty: Sentencer's Evaluation Of Mitigation And Aggravation
301.5.1 Death Penalty: The Sentencing Decision Must Be A Reasoned, Moral Response
301.5.2 Death Penalty: Jury Must Consider The Mix Of Factors
301.5.3 Death Penalty: Aggravation Does Not Need To Outweigh Mitigation Beyond A Reasonable Doubt
301.5.4 Mitigation And Aggravation Must Be Defined
301.5.5 Death Penalty: Life Verdict Permissible Even If Aggravating Factor Is Found
301.5.6 Burden Of Persuasion
301.5.7 Death Penalty: Weighing Or Nonweighing
301.5.8 Death Penalty: Imposition Of Sentence Under Impermissible Standard As Implicating The 8th Amendment
301.6 Death Penalty: Greater Reliability Is Required
301.6.1 Death Is Different
301.6.2 Death Penalty: Greater Reliability Required In Determining Guilt
301.6.3 Death Penalty: Sentencing Decision Must Be Reliable
301.6.4 Death Is Worse Then Life Imprisonment
301.6.5 Death Penalty: Greater Obligation Of Counsel To Investigate
301.6.6 Death Penalty: Constitutional Challenge Based On Unreliability
301.7 Death Penalty: Defendant’s Right To Personal Presence
301.7.1 Death Penalty: Defendant's Right To Personal Presence -- General Principles
301.7.2 Death Penalty: Defendant Has Right To Be Present At The Verdict
301.8 Death Penalty: Miscellaneous Constitutional Principles
301.8.1 Death Penalty: Sentencing Proceeding: Applicability Of Due Process
301.8.2 Death Penalty: Sentencer May Not Rely On Undisclosed Information
301.8.3 Death Penalty: Sentencing Proceeding: Right To Confrontation
301.8.4 Death Penalty: Defendant Has Due Process Right To Assistance Of Expert
301.8.5 Death Penalty: Duty Of Counsel To Request Appointment Of Mental Health Expert In Death Penalty Case
301.8.6 Death Penalty: Defendant’s Right To Capital Sentencing Instructions That The Jury Understands
301.8.7 Death Penalty: Prosecutorial Misconduct During Summation Or Argument To Jury
301.8.8 Whether Judge May Make The Sentencing Decision In A Death Penalty Trial
301.8.9 Public Favor Of Capital Punishment Must Not Impair Defendant’s Constitutional Right To A Fair Trial
301.9 Death Penalty: Conviction Of The Innocent
301.9.1 Death Penalty: Danger Of Executing Innocent Persons As Basis For Constitutional Challenge To Capital Punishment
Chapter 302: Death Penalty: Determination Of Death Eligibility (Death Qualification) – Issues And Instructions
302.1 General Principles
302.1.1 Death Eligibility Determination Requires Full Federal Constitutional Due Process And Trial By Jury Protections
302.1.2 Death Eligibility: Applicability Of Circumstantial Evidence Rules
302.1.3 Death Penalty: Constitutionality Of Executing The Mentally Retarded
302.1.4 Death Penalty: Constitutionality Of Executing Juveniles
302.2 Felony Murder Death Qualifier
302.2.1 Felony Murder Death Qualifier: Reckless Indifference And Major Participant
302.2.1.1 Definition Of "Major Participant”
302.2.1.2 Reckless Indifference Requires Knowledge Of Higher Probability Of Death Than Normally Attends The Felony
302.2.1.3 Reckless Indifference: Factors For The Jury To Consider
302.2.1.4 Felony Murder Death Qualifier: Reckless Indifference Should Be Defined
302.2.1.5 Felony Murder Death Qualifier: Reckless Indifference Requires Subjective Awareness
302.2.1.6 Felony Murder Death Qualifier: Requires Subjective Appreciation Of The Life-Threatening Risk, Even If Defendant Was A Major Participant
302.2.1.7 Felony Murder Death Qualifier: Actual Killer Must Be "Major Participant" And Have Reckless Indifference
302.2.1.8 "Major" Participant Felony Murder Death Qualifier: Constitutional Challenge
302.2.2 Felony Murder Death Qualifier: Miscellaneous Issues
302.2.2.1 Felony Murder Death Qualifier Application Of Merger Doctrine
302.2.2.2 Felony Murder Death Qualifier: Incidental Intent Not Sufficient
302.2.2.3 Felony Murder Death Qualifier: Duty To Instruct On Defenses When Underlying/Predicate Felony Is Not Charged
302.2.2.4 Felony Murder Special: Reckless Indifference As Unconstitutionally Vague
302.2.2.5 Overbreadth Constitutional Challenge To Felony Murder Death Qualifier
302.2.2.6 Duplication Of Elements In Felony Murder Death Qualifier As 8th Amendment Violation
302.3 Financial Gain Death Qualifier
302.3.1 Financial Gain Death Qualifier: Role Of Motive Instruction
302.3.2 Financial Gain Death Qualifier: Victim's Death Must Be Essential Prerequisite
302.4 Death Qualification: Murder To Prevent Arrest Or Perfect Escape
302.4.1 Requirement Of Intent
302.4.2 Death Qualification: Based On Escape -- Inapplicable If Escape Was Already Complete
302.5 Death Qualification: Miscellaneous Issues
302.5.1 "Depravity Of Mind" As Unconstitutional Death Qualification
302.5.2 “Outrageously Or Wantonly Vile” Death Qualifier
302.5.3 “Wicked Or Morally Corrupt” Death Qualifier
302.5.4 “Heinous, Cruel Or Depraved” Death Qualifier
302.5.5 “Torture, Depravity Of Mind Or Mutilation” Death Qualifier
302.5.6 “Utter Disregard For Human Life" Death Qualifier
302.5.7 Multiple Murder Death Qualifier: Overbreadth Constitutional Challenge
302.5.8 Definition Of Destructive Device
302.5.9 Death Eligibility: Murder Of Police Officer, Etc. -- Knowledge Requirement
302.5.10 Applicability Of Merger Doctrine To Arson Death Qualifier
Chapter 303: Death Penalty: Determination Of Sentence -- Issues And Instructions
303.1 Death Penalty: Determination Of Sentence -- General Principles
303.1.1 Death Penalty Trial: Introduction
303.1.2 Death Penalty Investigation Strategies
303.1.3 Death Penalty: Death Is Different
303.1.4 Juries Should Assume That Death Sentence Will Be Carried Out
303.1.5 Juror Misunderstanding Of Instructions In Death Cases Has Been Demonstrated
303.1.6 Death Penalty: Greater Obligation Of Counsel To Investigate
303.2 Death Penalty: Determination Of Sentence -- Procedural And Evidentiary Issues
303.2.1 Death Penalty: Admonition To Refrain From Considering Penalty During Guilt Phase
303.2.2 Death Penalty: Jury Must Not Consider Penalty Between Guilt And Penalty Phase Trials
303.2.3 Death Penalty: Whether Jury Should Be Reinstructed With Guilt Phase Instructions At The Penalty Trial
303.2.4 Death Penalty: Jury To Disregard Specified Evidence From The Guilt Trial
303.2.5 Death Penalty: Counsel's Duty To Seek Life Even Against Defendant's Wishes
303.2.6 Death Penalty: Admission Of Evidence Regarding Prior Death Sentence Does Not Violate 8th Amendment
303.2.7 Death Penalty: Applicability Of Accomplice Instructions To Penalty Phase
303.2.8 Death Penalty Mitigation: Relaxed Standards Regarding Admission Of Evidence
303.2.9 Death Penalty: Consideration Of Limited-Purpose Evidence For Mitigation At Penalty Trial
303.2.10 Death Penalty: Limitation On Bad Character Evidence Presented At Guilt Phase -- Applicability To Penalty Phase
303.2.11 Death Penalty: Cautionary/Limiting Instructions When Expert's Beliefs About The Death Penalty Are Elicited
303.2.12 Federal Constitution Violated By Omission Of Instruction Required By Death Penalty Statute
303.2.13 Death Penalty: Mental Health Defenses – Sealing Examination Results That Will Only Be Used In Penalty Phase Until Penalty Phase
303.3 Death Penalty: Sentencing Deliberation Issues
303.3.1 Death Penalty: Factors For Consideration At Penalty Trial
303.3.2 Death Penalty: Individual Juror Determination Of Aggravation And Mitigation
303.3.3 Death Penalty: Failure To Label Factors As Mitigating Or Aggravating
303.3.4 Death Penalty: Jury May Not Consider Deterrence Or Monetary Cost
303.3.5 Error to Instruct Jury That Death Penalty Is Mandatory If Aggravating Circumstances Found
303.3.6 Death Penalty: Prohibition Against Consideration Of Race, Religion, National Origin Or Gender Of Either Victim Or Defendant
303.3.7 Death Penalty: Jury May Return Verdict Of Life Even If Aggravation Outweighs Mitigation
303.3.8 Death Penalty: Duty to Deliberate At Penalty Proceeding
303.3.9 Death Penalty: Jury Does Not Have Duty To Reach A Verdict
303.3.10 Death Penalty: Jurors Must Not Place Themselves "In The Shoes" Of The Victim Or Defendant
303.3.11 Death Penalty: Jury Should Not Be Informed About Defendant’s Right To Appeal
303.3.12 Death Penalty: Jury Not To Simply Count Aggravating And Mitigating Factors
303.3.13 Death Penalty: Right To Instruction That Death Is The Greater Penalty
303.3.14 Death Penalty: Individualized Consideration For Accomplice
303.3.15 Death Penalty: Improper To Require Rejection Of Death Before Consideration Of Life Verdict
303.3.16 Death Penalty: Jurors Must Disregard Alleged But Unproven Aggravating Factor
303.3.17 Responding To Jury Inquiries In Capital Cases
303.4 Death Penalty: Mitigation – Miscellaneous Issues
303.4.1 Death Penalty: Reliable Mitigating Evidence Not Admissible In Guilt Trial May Be Admissible At The Penalty Phase
303.4.2 Death Penalty: Single Mitigating Circumstance Sufficient For Life Verdict
303.4.3 Death Penalty: Use of the Term "Totality" Improperly Implies That One Mitigating Factor May Not Outweigh All Factors In Aggravation
303.4.4 Death Penalty: Scope Of Mitigation -- No Mitigation Necessary To Reject Death
303.4.5 Death Penalty: Mitigation Includes Post-Arrest Factors
303.4.6 Death Penalty: Felony Murder -- Individualized Consideration Of Defendant’s Participation And Culpability
303.4.7 Death Penalty: Unanimity Not A Requirement For Consideration Of Mitigating Evidence
303.4.8 Death Penalty: Absence Of Mitigation Is Not Aggravation
303.4.9 Death Penalty: Jury's Consideration Of Mitigating Evidence May Be Guided
303.5 Death Penalty: List Of Mitigating Factors Not Exclusive
303.5.1 Death Penalty: List Of Mitigating Factors Not Exclusive -- General Principles
303.5.2 Jury Must Be Permitted to Consider Nonstatutory Mitigation
303.5.3 Modification Of “Catch-All” Mitigation Instruction To Pinpoint Defense Theories
303.5.4 Death Penalty: Checklist Of Potential Specific Mitigating Factors Included In Catch-All Mitigation Instruction
303.5.5 Death Penalty: Prospects For Rehabilitation As Mitigating Factor
303.6 Death Penalty: Consideration Of Defendant’s Individual Role
303.6.1 Defendant's Minimal Participation As Mitigating Factor
303.7 Death Penalty: Specific Mitigating Factors
303.7.1 Death Penalty: Miscellaneous Mitigating Factors
303.7.1.1 Death Penalty: Courtroom Observations Of Defendant As Basis For Not Imposing Death
303.7.1.2 Effect Of Death Penalty On The Defendant's Family As Mitigation
303.7.1.3 Death Penalty: Polygraph As Mitigation
303.7.1.4 Death Penalty: Leniency Received By Accomplice As Mitigation
303.7.1.5 Death Penalty: Defendant's Background Is Mitigating Only
303.7.1.6 Death Penalty: Good Prison Behavior/Potential For Rehabilitation As Mitigation
303.7.1.7 Death Penalty: Mental Retardation As Mitigation
303.7.1.8 Death Penalty: Lack Of Significant Prior Criminal
303.7.1.9 Death Penalty: Coercion As Mitigation
303.7.1.10 Death Penalty: Good Character As Mitigation
303.7.1.11 “Catch All” Mitigation Factor
303.7.2 Death Penalty: Mental Impairment As Mitigation
303.7.2.1 Death Penalty: Extreme Mental Or Emotional Disturbance -- Reasonable Person Standard Inapplicable
303.7.2.2 Death Penalty: Mental Impairment Not Limited To Excuse Or Negation Of An Element
303.7.2.3 Death Penalty: Mental Illness, Emotional Disturbance And Retardation As Mitigating Factors Upon Which Jury Must Be Instructed
303.7.2.4 Death Penalty: Consideration Of Less Than Extreme Mental Or Emotional Disturbance
303.7.2.5 Death Penalty: Mental Impairment Not Limited To Excuse Or Negation Of An Element / (F 8.85(h) Inst 1)
303.7.2.6 Mental Or Emotional Disturbance As Mitigation: Consideration Contributing Circumstances
303.7.3 Death Penalty: Lingering Or Residual Doubt As Mitigation
303.7.3.1 Whether Lingering Doubt Or Residual Doubt As To Guilt Is Mitigation
303.7.3.2 Strategy When Court Contends That Lingering Doubt Is Included In General "Catch-All" Mitigating Factors
303.7.3.3 Lingering Doubt As To Extent Or Degree Of Defendant's Guilt
303.7.3.4 Lingering Doubt Or Residual Doubt: Combining With Other Mitigating Evidence
303.7.3.5 Lingering Doubt Or Residual Doubt: Multiple Defendants
303.7.4 Death Penalty: Lack Of Significant Criminal Record As Mitigation
303.7.4.1 Absence Of Prior Felony Conviction As Mitigation
303.7.4.2 Absence Of Violent Criminal Activity As Mitigation
303.7.4.3 Evidentiary Showing Necessary For Instruction On Lack Of Criminal Record Or Activity
303.7.4.4 Death Penalty: Defense Theory That Nonviolent Prior Criminal Activity Or Convictions Are Mitigating
303.7.4.5 Prior Felony Convictions: Instructions Given Must Be Correct
303.7.5 Death Penalty: Remorse As Mitigation
303.7.5.1 Remorse As Mitigation For Jury To Consider
303.7.5.2 Remorse As Mitigation: Conflict Between Codefendants When One Relies On Remorse And The Other Doesn't
303.7.5.3 Remorse As Mitigation: Conflict Between Codefendant's Regarding Right To Testify And Right To Allocution
303.7.5.4 Death Penalty: Improper To Infer Lack Of Remorse From Failure Of Defendant To Confess
303.7.5.5 Capital Trial: No Consideration Of Nontestimonial Appearance Or Demeanor
303.7.6 Death Penalty: Youth Or Immaturity As Mitigation
303.7.6.1 Age As Mitigation: Immaturity, Not Just Chronological Age, Must Be Considered
303.7.6.2 Jury Should Compare Defendant's Age With The Statutory Age When Death Eligibility Begins
303.7.7 Advanced Age As Mitigation
303.7.7.1 Advanced Age As Mitigation
303.7.7.2 Advanced Age As Mitigation: Physiological Age Should Be Considered In Addition To Chronological Age
303.7.8 Death Penalty: Physical Abuse Of Defendant As Mitigation
303.7.8.1 Family History As Mitigation
303.7.8.2 Death Penalty Mitigation: Physical Abuse Of Defendant As Child Is Relevant Mitigating Evidence Even Without Expert Testimony
303.7.8.3 Childhood Victimization As Mitigation
303.7.9 Sympathy As Mitigation
303.7.9.1 Scope And Proof Of Mitigation: Sympathy Alone Is Sufficient To Reject Death
303.7.9.2 Death Penalty: Defendant's Courtroom Demeanor As Basis For Sympathy
303.7.10 Mitigating Evidence: Exclusion Of Evidence Regarding Defendant’s Family Members
303.7.10 Mitigating Evidence: Exclusion Of Evidence Regarding Defendant’s Family Members
303.8 Death Penalty: Aggravation: Miscellaneous Issues
303.8.1 Death Penalty: Aggravating Circumstances Of The Offense Factor Is Vague And Ambiguous
303.8.2 Death Penalty: Seeking to Exclude Nonstatutory Aggravating Evidence
303.8.3 Death Penalty: Aggravation Limited To Enumerated Statutory Factors
303.8.4 Prior Violent Felony Conviction As Aggravating Factor -- Not Applicable To Accessory After The Fact
303.8.5 Defense Theory That Defendant's Inability To Express His Or Her Emotions Negate Premeditation And Deliberation
303.8.6 Death Penalty: Jurors Must Disregard Alleged But Unproven Aggravating Factor
303.9 Death Penalty: Unadjudicated Prior Crimes As Aggravation
303.9.1 Unadjudicated Violent Crimes: Duty To Instruct Upon Available Defenses To Those Crimes
303.9.2 Unadjudicated Violent Offenses: Applicable Only To Crimes Directed Against A Person
303.9.3 Unadjudicated Violent Offenses: Duty To Instruct On Elements
303.9.4 Prior Conviction In Death Penalty Trial: Limiting Instruction Required Sua Sponte
303.10 Death Penalty: Victim Impact As Sentencing Factor
303.10.1 Victim Impact: Combined Limiting Instruction
303.10.2 Victim Impact Limited To Rational, Rather Than Emotional, Response
303.10.3 Victim Impact: Jury Must Not Consider Overly Emotional Evidence
303.10.4 Victim Impact Not Aggravation -- Does Not Relieve Prosecution Of Burden Of Proving Death Qualification/Eligibility
303.10.5 Victim Impact: Right Of Defendant To Present Negative Evidence Regarding Victim
303.10.6 Improper For Victims To Expound On Appropriate Sentence For Defendant
303.10.7 Victim Impact: Improper To Measure Relative Worth Of Defendant And Victim
303.10.8 Victim Impact: Notice Requirement
303.10.9 Victim Impact Limited To Victims Of Crimes Proven At Guilt Phase And Directly Related To The Capital Offense
303.10.10 Victim Impact Limited To Circumstances About Which Defendant Was Aware
303.10.11 Necessity Of Pre-Hearing In Limine Motion To Exclude Or Limit Victim Impact Evidence
303.10.12 Jury Should Consider Opinion Of Victim Impact Witness That Defendant Should Not Be Executed
303.10.13 Victim Impact: Irrelevant To Determination Of Aggravating Circumstances
303.10.14 Victim Impact: Cautionary And Limiting Instruction
303.10.15 Victim Impact: Tactical Considerations Before the Jury
303.10.16 Victim Impact: Improper Characterization Of The Defendant
303.11 Challenge To "Double Counting" Of Aggravating Factors
303.11.1 Death Penalty: Improper To “Double Count” Aggravating Factors Which Were Also Used As Death Qualifiers
303.11.2 Death Penalty: Conviction Of Defendant Of First Degree Murder Is Not Itself An Aggravating Factor
303.12 Death Penalty: Meaning Of Sentencing Options
303.12.1 Instruction As To Meaning Of Life Without Parole: Sample Argument To The Jury In Cases Where Instruction Is Refused
303.12.2 Instruction As To Meaning Of Life Imprisonment Without Parole
303.12.3 Whether Jury May Consider The Unlikelihood of Executive Clemency
303.12.4 Instruction As To Meaning Of Life Without Parole
303.12.5 Death Penalty: Confusing Jury Instruction Regarding Possibility Of Parole
303.12.6 Death Penalty: Improper For Commutation Instruction To Imply The Question Of Release Will Automatically Come Before The Governor
303.12.7 Death Penalty: Meaning Of Life Without Parole – Presentation Of Statistical Information Relating To Commutation
303.12.8 Instruction On Meaning Of Life Imprisonment: Empirical Evidence Of Prejudice
303.13 Jury Must Not Consider Deterrence
303.13.1 Death Penalty: Jury May Not Consider Deterrence Or Monetary Cost
303.14 Failure Of Defendant To Testify
303.14.1 No Adverse Inference As To Penalty From Failure Of Defendant To Testify At Guilt Or Penalty Trial
303.15 Death Penalty: Informing Jury As To Consequences Of Failure To Reach A Verdict As To Penalty
303.15.1 Death Penalty: Consequences Of Failure To Agree At Penalty: Jury Should Be Informed That Guilt Phase Verdicts Will Not Be Affected
303.16 Death Penalty: Future Dangerousness
303.16.1 Death Penalty: Admissibility Of Psychiatric Testimony On Future Dangerousness
303.16.2 Death Penalty: Expert Opinion As To Future Dangerousness – Cautionary Concerns
303.16.3 Death Penalty: Future Dangerousness: Exclusion Of Evidence Under Daubert/Kumho
303.16.4 Death Penalty: Gang Evidence Improper Where Future Dangerousness Not Raised
303.17 Death Penalty: Appellate Review Of Sentencing Determination
303.17.1 Right To Meaningful Appellate Review
303.17.2 Review Required In Nonweighing State
303.17.3 Review Of Invalid Or Insufficient Aggravating Factors
Chapter 304: Federal Death Penalty Statute
304.1 Federal Death Penalty Statute: Resources
304.2 Federal Death Penalty: Discriminatory Effect
304.3 Federal Death Penalty: Failure Of Attorney General To Follow Procedural Protocol
304.4 Federal Death Penalty: Lack Of Proportionality Review
304.5 Federal Death Penalty: Sample Jury Instructions
304.6 Federal Death Penalty: Constitutional Challenge
304.7 Federal Death Penalty: Pecuniary Gain Aggravator Requires Expectation Of Gain As A Result Of The Murder
304.8 Federal Death Penalty: Clarifying Distinction In Burdens As To Aggravation And Mitigation
304.9 Federal Death Penalty: Unanimity – Individual Juror Has Power To Prevent Death Sentence |